A Christmas Carol | film by Hurst [1951] | Britannica A Christmas Carol by Brian Desmond Hurst |Alastair Sim, Kathleen Humbug to all the rest: Why the 1951 Scrooge film is considered Amazon.com: A Christmas Carol: Ultimate 2 Dvd Collector’s Edition a christmas carol” remains the BEST adaptation ever!!! Alastair A Christmas Carol [Scrooge] (1951) HD. Alastair Sim, Jack Warner a christmas carol” remains the BEST adaptation ever!!! Alastair Rent A Christmas Carol (1951) on DVD and Blu ray DVD Netflix Scrooge, (aka A Christmas Carol), Alastair Sim, Michael Dolan